In this episode of Idol Memories, American Idol Executive Producer, Nigel Lythgoe, is taking us back to season one’s second semi-final round. From the performances to the judges’ feedback, Nigel remembers every detail. Then he chats with Jim Verraros, who placed ninth in the first season, about his controversial elimination and reinstatement into the competition. They go on to discuss Verraros’ experience being a “guinea pig” for a new reality television show.
On this episode of Idol Memories, Nigel Lythgoe covers:

The first season’s second semi-final round

Jim Verraros’ reaction to his unaired and revoked elimination

Who Verraros thought was going to win

Verraros’ memories of fellow contestants & the experience of being on a new reality show