Season 1: Delphi Episode 3: Unthinkable
Abby and Libby were found dead in a secluded wooded area between the Morning Heights Cemetery and the Monon High Bridge. But more devastating news soon followed: the girls had been murdered. And the authorities had photos of someone they wanted to talk to in connection with the deaths of Abby and Libby. What’s more, they had his voice.
If you have any information about Libby and Abby, please call the tip line at 1-844-459-5786 or send email
Episode Credits-
Narration: Natalie Gray
Research and writing: Jessica Bettencourt
Technical adviser: Gray Hughes
Consulting Producer: Kelsi German
Producers: Gray Hughes, Jessica Bettencourt, Mike Morford
Executive Producer: Mike Morford of AbJack Entertainment
Special thanks to: the families of Liberty German and Abigail Williams, Kelsi German, Mike Patty, Becky Patty, and Anna Williams. Thanks also goes out to Indiana State Police Superintendent, Doug Carter, Robert Ives, Paul Holes, Dr. Katherine M. Brown, Colleen Fitzpatrick, Drew Collins, Michel Bennett, and Bree Wilber
You can find Scene of the Crime Podcast on Twitter with the handle @SceneOfCrimePod

To listen to every episode of this show AD-FREE and get benefits like bonus and early-access episodes of every other show on the AbJack Network, consider an AbJack Insider subscription from Apple Podcasts.