Did everyone forget Scott saying he wanted to kiss Gabby in Casa Amor???....yes, he didn't actually do it, but that's only because Sammy got to her first and she ended up liking Sammy more. The girls are saying it how it isWhether or not you like it, it's the truth. They wouldn't have been saying the harsh truth so blatantly if he wasn't using his supposed "loyalty" as a way to try and make Cat feel guilty about exploring. Also, there is definitely something that we're missing, something that the producers haven't shown us because the whole Catherine & Scott situation after Casa Amore is not adding up. Not just in Cat's reaction but also the girls. Things aren't adding up, they are all LOVING Elom for her and absolutely shitting on Scott... all of them, as a collective, so something must've happened or they may have seen something in his actions towards her to make them all agree simultaneously.