John Mayer, the renowned singer-songwriter, is reportedly feeling "annoyed" and frustrated by the persistent rumors and hints that he once had a romantic encounter with reality TV star Scheana Shay. According to a recent report by the U.S. Sun, Mayer has been asserting to his close friends and associates that he has never been involved with Shay, despite her not-so-subtle insinuations during a recent episode of the popular reality series "Vanderpump Rules." An insider close to the situation revealed to the outlet that Mayer has been openly discussing the matter with several people in his inner circle, adamantly denying any past involvement with Shay. "John has told several people close to him that he never hooked up with Scheana," the source stated, emphasizing the singer's frustration with the ongoing speculation. The insider further elaborated on the timeline of the rumors, indicating that Mayer has been aware of Shay's claims for some time, even before the airing of the "Vanderpump Rules" episode that brought the topic to the forefront. "He knows that she has been telling people they hooked up well before the 'Vanderpump Rules' episode aired and it's gotten back to him," the source added, highlighting the extent of Mayer's displeasure with the situation. Mayer's annoyance with the persistent rumors has apparently reached a boiling point, with the insider noting, "He's very annoyed by the entire thing and wants nothing to do with her." The singer's desire to distance himself from the reality star and the ongoing speculation about their alleged past is evident in his reported actions at a recent party attended by both Mayer and Shay. According to the source, the "Gravity" hitmaker, 46, made a concerted effort to avoid any interaction with Shay, 38, at the event. "She was trying her best to talk to John and even go as far as take a picture with him, but he shot her down," the insider claimed, painting a picture of Mayer's firm stance on the matter and his unwillingness to engage with Shay in any capacity. The rumors of a past encounter between Mayer and Shay gained traction earlier this month when the reality star hinted at a previous orgy involving an "A-list celebrity" during a game of "Never Have I Ever" with her "Vanderpump Rules" castmates. While Shay did not explicitly name the celebrity in question, she made a playful reference to Mayer's most recognizable song, quipping, "Once upon a time, my body was a wonderland," leaving little doubt about the identity of the alleged partner. This is not the first time Shay has alluded to a past dalliance with Mayer. During a 2020 episode of the "Flashbacks" podcast, the Bravolebrity recounted her initial meeting with the singer and his then-girlfriend, actress Jennifer Aniston, whom he dated from 2008 to 2009. Shay claimed that she was working a party where she encountered the couple and ended up "getting wasted with them," participating in shots alongside the famous duo. Following Mayer's split from Aniston, Shay alleged that she began seeing the singer, claiming, "I was living with ['The Hills' alum Stacie Adams] at the time. This went on for about six months. … It just became, you know, kind of the three of us. We had a little throuple going on." These statements further fueled the speculation surrounding the nature of Shay's relationship with Mayer. Despite the ongoing rumors and Shay's hints at a past involvement, Mayer has remained steadfast in his denial of any romantic connection with the reality star. The singer's representatives have not yet provided an official comment on the matter when contacted by Page Six. While Mayer continues to navigate the unwanted attention and speculation surrounding his alleged past with Shay, the "Good As Gold" songstress has moved on in her personal life. Shay found love with her now-husband, Brock Davies, whom she married in 2021. The couple welcomed their daughter, Summer Moon, the same year, and appear to be happily focused on their family life. The persistent rumors and hints about a past encounter between John Mayer and Scheana Shay have undoubtedly caused frustration and annoyance for the singer, who has reportedly been vocal about his lack of involvement with the reality star. As Mayer continues to assert his stance on the matter to his close friends and associates, it remains to be seen whether the speculation will eventually subside or if Shay will continue to fuel the rumors with her cryptic references and allusions to a shared past.
Regardless of the truth behind the alleged encounter, it is clear that Mayer is eager to distance himself from the ongoing speculation and maintain his focus on his successful music career. With a string of hit songs and a dedicated fan base, the singer-songwriter's talent and artistry have long been the driving force behind his enduring popularity, overshadowing any tabloid rumors or reality TV drama. As the situation continues to unfold, it is likely that both Mayer and Shay will face ongoing scrutiny and questioning from curious fans and media outlets alike. However, for Mayer, the priority seems to be setting the record straight and moving forward without the distraction of unsubstantiated rumors and unwanted attention. In the end, the truth about any past involvement between John Mayer and Scheana Shay may remain a mystery, known only to the individuals directly involved. But one thing is certain: the singer's reported frustration and annoyance with the persistent speculation serve as a reminder of the challenges that come with life in the public eye, where even the most private moments can become fodder for gossip and speculation. Thanks for listening to Quiet Please. Remember to like and share wherever you get your podcasts.